tv

Reasons for É neutrality during World War Two

The day after Britain declared war on Germany, Éamon de Valera confirmed É’s .

Question

Why did de Valera opt for neutrality during World War Two?

Back to top

Attitude of the people of É towards neutrality

Although many in É sympathised with the Allied cause, was popular.

The majority of the population supported neutrality because it was a British, not an Irish, war.

Many believed neutrality was a good way of asserting their independence from Britain.

They also hoped it might save Ireland from the horrors of modern warfare.

Even Ireland’s minority supported neutrality, whilst still backing the Allied war effort.

Only a small number of people advocated abandoning neutrality.

This number increased when the USA joined the war in December 1941, but it was never a widespread opinion.

Back to top

The response of Northern Ireland and Britain to É neutrality

Britain's response

Although Winston Churchill had warned that É co-operation with Britain in a war was unlikely, many expected É would help, and in particular let Britain use the former and other military bases.

The British only accepted É reluctantly.

They wanted to end it as:

  • Britain was suffering heavy shipping losses in the Atlantic. Re-routing British ships to ports in Northern Ireland, instead of using ports in É, was placing a great strain on the vital supply route across the Atlantic.
  • Britain was worried that Germany might invade É and use it as a ‘stepping stone’ from which to attack Britain.
  • É did not have regulations. Therefore, Northern Ireland was an easily identifiable target for the .

However, realising the importance of good communication, Sir John Maffey was appointed as the British Government’s representative to É.

He developed a positive relationship with de Valera.

However, British pressure to end the policy remained strong, particularly after Churchill became Prime Minister in May 1940.

Northern Ireland's response

There was strong resentment at É’s in Northern Ireland.

It was viewed as an act of betrayal and a threat to the United Kingdom’s security.

Overall, the war led to a further decline in north-south relations.

They clashed over:

  • The lack of a in É, which the unionists believed increased the probability of Northern Ireland being targeted by German bombers.
  • De Valera not expelling Hempel, the German in Dublin.
  • De Valera’s campaign for for Tom Williams, an man sentenced to death for his part in a gun battle with police in West Belfast.
  • De Valera’s repeated demands for an end to .
  • The issue of (1941).
  • Workers from É taking what unionist regarded as their jobs in Belfast.
  • Thus, by 1945 the relationship between the Northern in the north and Southern was extremely hostile.

Unionists were not aware of É’s benevolent neutrality.

However, de Valera's quick response during the Belfast in 1941, through the supply of fire-fighters to help in Belfast, was greatly appreciated at the time.

Back to top

É neutrality in practice

É asserted its as follows:

  • It refused military assistance to both sides.
  • The Allies were denied the use of ports and airfields.
  • News bulletins gave purely factual reports about the war.
  • Weather forecasts ceased to be broadcast in case they helped either side.
  • When the US entered the war, de Valera resisted US pressure to end neutrality.
  • Indeed, de Valera went to great lengths to appear neutral.

He irritated Washington by protesting at the arrival of US troops in Northern Ireland.

He also annoyed Allied opinion when he expressed sympathy over Hitler’s death.

However, he had also expressed sympathy at the death of US President, Franklin Delano Roosevelt.

'Benevolent neutrality'

##

Frequently Dublin’s actions made it seem that its was pro-Allies.

This help was known as 'benevolent neutrality'.

Examples of this were:

  • In 1943, the German radio transmitter was confiscated.
  • German pilots who bailed out over É were ; Allied airmen were allowed to cross the border into Northern Ireland,
  • During the 1941 Belfast , de Valera sent fire crews from Drogheda and Dundalk to help.
  • In the aftermath of the Belfast Blitz, relief centres were set up close to the border and relief funds were started.
  • Allied airmen patrolling the or refuelling on trans-Atlantic missions could fly over Irish territory via the . This saved a 100-mile detour.
  • Coastal were provided for US airmen.
  • Weather reports were secretly transmitted to the Allies, and proved very valuable during the in June 1944.
  • In the final months of the war, de Valera allowed the to establish secret bases in É.
  • Plans were drawn up by both countries for joint co-operation if Germany invaded É, and for the British army based in Northern - Ireland to move into the South.
  • However, all co-operation was kept secret; most members of the British and Irish government were unaware of it.

Question

What were the real reasons for É’s ability to remain ?

Quiz: É neutrality

Back to top

Reaction to Britain’s offer to end partition

Britain made several attempts to persuade É to enter the war on the Allies’ side.

In June 1940, Churchill proposed ending in return for British forces using É naval bases.

De Valera refused as:

  • He was unsure if the British could be trusted to honour the decision after the war.
  • He doubted that could be forced into a united Ireland against their will.
  • He thought Britain might lose the war, thus making the promise worthless.
  • He did not want to compromise É hard won independence from Britain by having British troops back in É.
  • Following the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor (7 December 1941), Churchill de Valera.

His offer of 'Now is your chance. Now or never “A nation once again”’, was understood by de Valera to refer to the possibility of Irish unity if he joined the Allies.

Now is your chance. Now or never “A nation once again.”
– Winston Churchill to Éamon de Valera 1941

Again he declined.

In 1942, Churchill again attempted to regain the use of the .

Once again, his efforts were rejected.

Back to top

Pressure on É to end neutrality

Economic pressure

Britain reduced the number of its ships used both to transport goods to É and to protect Irish cargo vessels.

Due to , É was not able to access financial aid under the USA’s programme.

Propaganda pressure

As the war continued, É came under increasing pressure from both sides of the Atlantic to join the fighting.

After the USA joined the war in December 1941, President Roosevelt put pressure on É to join the Allies.

He felt É’s was detrimental to the war effort, so a media campaign portraying de Valera as pro-German was launched.

Relations deteriorated further in 1942 when, in spite of de Valera’s protests, US troops arrived in Northern Ireland to train and to help with defence.

Back to top

Actions taken by É to maintain its neutrality

##

Maintaining was difficult.

To achieve it, É government did the following:

  1. The used its extensive new powers under the . There was strict of the press and radio. No negative comments were permitted and weather reports were not published in case they helped either side in the war.
  2. De Valera used the and the to deal decisively with the .
  3. É ensured it received essential supplies previously brought by British ships by setting up a Ministry of Supplies under Seán Lemass.
  4. É defences were strengthened.
Back to top

Test your knowledge

Back to top

More on Changing relations: Northern Ireland and its neighbours, 1920-49

Find out more by working through a topic