±«Óãtv

Human values evaluation of a multi-device classical music experience

Paper 405: Would an experience where listeners could focus on certain instruments fare better than a stereo recording?

Published: 1 March 2023
Icons from ±«Óãtv R&D's work on human values - a heart, an anchored balloon, a plant, a person running through a tape at a finish line.
  • Jon Francombe (BMus Ph.D.)

    Jon Francombe (BMus Ph.D.)

    Lead Research & Development Engineer
  • Lianne Kerlin

    Lianne Kerlin

    Research Scientist
  • Todd Burlington

    Graduate R&D Engineer
  • Kristian Hentschel

    Trainee Research Technologist

"Pick A Part" is a multi-device classical music experience that enables a listener to connect extra devices and use them to play individual instruments that are synchronised with the main device. This gives a listening experience that is interactive and immersive. ±«Óãtv R&D’s human values framework was used to evaluate the ability of the orchestration technology to enable audiences to be inspired, explore the world, pursue pleasure, and connect with others. An online experiment was performed with two groups of 50 participants; one group was presented with a standard stereo recording, and the other with the multi-device experience. After the experience, participants were asked to respond to questions about each value on five-point Likert scales, as well as giving free-text responses.

Statistical tests showed that the orchestrated version of Pick A Part was significantly better than the stereo version for enabling participants to explore the world, with some further significant differences in individual items from the pursuing pleasure value and between listeners with and without prior classical music listening experience. The qualitative data were analysed using thematic analysis, with results highlighting the learning benefits and heightened immersion of the orchestrated condition. User experience results from the experiment as well as from a separate questionnaire conducted whilst Pick A Part was on ±«Óãtv Taster suggested that the technology was easy to use and showed that respondents would like to use orchestration again, including with different genres.

This white paper reflects the state of work originally completed in October 2021.

White Paper copyright

© ±«Óãtv. All rights reserved. Except as provided below, no part of a White Paper may be reproduced in any material form (including photocopying or storing it in any medium by electronic means) without the prior written permission of ±«Óãtv Research except in accordance with the provisions of the (UK) Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988.

The ±«Óãtv grants permission to individuals and organisations to make copies of any White Paper as a complete document (including the copyright notice) for their own internal use. No copies may be published, distributed or made available to third parties whether by paper, electronic or other means without the ±«Óãtv's prior written permission.

Rebuild Page

The page will automatically reload. You may need to reload again if the build takes longer than expected.

Useful links

Theme toggler

Select a theme and theme mode and click "Load theme" to load in your theme combination.

Theme:
Theme Mode: