Pavement Parking
Local councils in Scotland have been given the power to enforce fines to cars parked on pavements. What does this mean for local VI people and what is happening elsewhere?
The Transport (Scotland) Act has been in place since 2019, which includes a nation-wide ban of parking cars on pavements. But only in December 2023 were local councils across Scotland given the powers to enforce fines of up to Ā£100 to people doing so. Some local councils are saying that they need more funding and resources to be able to conduct assessments of their streets and to implement enforcement. We put this to Scotland's Transport Minister Fiona Hyslop and we hear from visually impaired resident of Glasgow about how pavement parking impacts her everyday journeys.
Meanwhile, The Thomas Pocklington Trust are reigniting a decade-old campaign that calls for a similar ban across England. The Trust's head of public affairs and campaigns, Mike Bell tells us what they're calling for.
Presenter: Peter White
Producer: Beth Hemmings
Production Coordinator: Liz Poole
Website image description: Peter White sits smiling in the centre of the image and he is wearing a dark green jumper. Above Peter's head is the ±«Óćtv logo (three separate white squares house each of the three letters). Bottom centre and overlaying the image are the words "In Touch" and the Radio 4 logo (the word Radio in a bold white font, with the number 4 inside a white circle). The background is a bright mid-blue with two rectangles angled diagonally to the right. Both are behind Peter, one is a darker blue and the other is a lighter blue.
Last on
More episodes
Previous
In Touch Transcript 09/01/2024
Downloaded from www.bbc.co.uk/radio4
Ģż
THE ATTACHED TRANSCRIPT WAS TYPED FROM A RECORDING AND NOT COPIED FROM AN ORIGINAL SCRIPT.Ģż BECAUSE OF THE RISK OF MISHEARING AND THE DIFFICULTY IN SOME CASES OF IDENTIFYING INDIVIDUAL SPEAKERS, THE ±«Óćtv CANNOT VOUCH FOR ITS COMPLETE ACCURACY.
Ģż
Ģż
IN TOUCH ā Pavement Parking
TX:Ģż 09.01.2024Ģż 2040-2100
PRESENTER:Ģż ĢżĢżĢżĢżĢżĢżĢżĢż PETER WHITE
Ģż
PRODUCER:ĢżĢżĢżĢżĢżĢżĢżĢżĢżĢżĢż BETH HEMMINGS
Ģż
Ģż
Ģż
White
Good evening.Ģż Even the mildest mannered of visually impaired people can be reduced to impotent fury by this:
Ģż
Clip
Lucy and I have just left the house.Ģż Weāve already come to a stop.Ģż Lucyās taken me up to the side of the road, as thereās a car on the pavement which is very common.Ģż Forward.Ģż Over.Ģż Iām now in the middle of the road, thereās quite a bit of noise down here, so I canāt hear if thereās any cars coming.Ģż Itās coming down dark, so itās even scarier because I have no useful vision at all during the dark.Ģż Good girl.Ģż It is just absolutely exasperating.Ģż Forward.Ģż Good girl.Ģż Good girl.
Ģż
White
Now there was some excitement back in 2019 when we were able to announce that Scotland was to be the first home country to make parking on pavements a statutory offence nationwide and that drivers breaking the rules could be subject to fines of up to Ā£100.Ģż At last, many of you told us, because this has been a problem sinceā¦ well, ever since motor vehicles and pedestrians were expected to co-exist.Ģż And yet only now is the Scottish act coming into force and already weāre hearing about some of the Scottish local authorities whoāve been given the powers to enforce it pushing back on the amount of work involved and the cost of enforcing it.Ģż Still, at least Scotland is doing something about it and in a moment weāll be hearing from the Transport Minister about the differences sheās hoping it will make.
Ģż
First though, Lyn Hetherington, whose voice we heard at the top of the programme as she struggled to navigate the roads around where she lives on the outskirts of Glasgow.
Ģż
Lyn, I mean, first of all, tell us a bit more about the hazards cars and other vehicles pose for you.
Ģż
Hetherington
Well, in my daily life it is a struggle.Ģż We come across cars on the pavement at least four or five times a day and thatās just in our local area without going into Glasgow.Ģż My guide dog, she goes to the side of the kerb when she comes to a car and thereās no space to get down the inside.Ģż Now she will take me off the pavement and I donāt have any distance vision whatsoever, so, I donāt know if itās a number of cars or just the one, so Iām going off the kerb with her help.Ģż But the scary part of it is you donāt know if youāre going to be meeting a car or if thereās going to be a car come up behind you, you just have to take your chances as far as thatās concerned.
Ģż
White
And have you had particularly bad experiences?
Ģż
Hetherington
Yes, my husbandās a guide dog owner as well.Ģż We did have one bad experience where we had to come off the pavement but it wasnāt for one car, it was for probably about 10-12 cars.Ģż There was a local football match on and the cars were all up on both sides of the road and we had no option, we couldnāt even cross the road to go on another pavement.Ģż So, that was actually quite scary.Ģż And one of the other times I had was actually when a vanā¦ when I was walking down the road the van crossed in front of me and went onto the pavement.Ģż And if that wasnāt bad enough, it decided to start reversing.
Ģż
White
Can I ask you ā do you ever challenge the people who put these vehicles in your path?
Ģż
Hetherington
My husband, he challenges people and he had one where he came off the kerb, had to go past this van that was completely on the pavement and the person inside was actually sitting having their lunch.Ģż So, my husband tackled him and the man came out of the van and started verbally abusing my husband who walked off at that point, didnāt want any more confrontation than that.Ģż So, yes, we do get confrontation from people who think that itās okay to do what theyāre doing.
Ģż
White
Now Iām sure youāre pleased that something, at least, is happening in Scotland but I think youāre still concerned about how quickly this will come into force.Ģż The council in your area ā Glasgow city ā has said:
Ģż
Glasgow city council statement
In line with Transport Scotland guidance we are undertaking a full assessment of footway parking throughout the city to help us establish if it would be appropriate to exempt any streets from the pavement parking ban.Ģż Once our footway assessment is complete a report will be put before committee in due course.
Ģż
Lyn, how confident does that make you feel?
Ģż
Hetherington
That actually makes me feel as if Iām back to square one because Iām a lot in the city centre, itās usually bigger vehicles, so itās longer spaces but you donāt come off the kerb there, as nobody would walk up a street in the middle of Glasgow, so, you need to actually backtrack, you need to find a crossing, you need to go up the other side of the road and then find another crossing to get back and double back.Ģż People are reasonable, we understand that there are places that this is not going to manage to happen but to have to think that theyāre starting that now, youāre talking another year or two years before they get finished.
Ģż
White
Okay, stay with us.Ģż Listening to that has been the Scottish Transport Minister, Fiona Hyslop.Ģż Minister, thanks for coming on.Ģż How soon do you think itāll be before Lyn can walk her streets more confidently?
Ģż
Hyslop
Well, I agree that pavement parking needs to end, itās unfair, itās unsafe and itās been illegal in Scotland since 2019.Ģż Now remember the Transport Act came in on November 2019 just before the pandemic.Ģż Since then, obviously, weāve tried ensure all the different regulations have been brought in, there was a disruption to that timescale but the exemption, youāve been talking about, the powers for councils to exempt, have been in place for some time and itāll be up to individual councils, who know their streets better than clearly central government to understand which ones they can exempt or should exempt and which not to. ĢżIām very pleased that Edinburgh City Council have taken a lead, theyāve already put forward their proposals to the relevant council committee and will be enforcing the new powers, which we brought in to effect in December last year to have the ability to fine people who are parking illegally, and theyāre bringing their powers into force practically from the end of this month.
Ģż
White
But Lynās point was, you know, shouldnāt this work, about which Glasgow and many other councils have been talking, shouldnāt they have been carried out back in 2019 rather than waiting for the full enforcement of this act last month?
Ģż
Hyslop
So, Iām the transport minister for Scotland, we brought forward, I think, groundbreaking legislation that enables local authorities right across the country to tackle pavement parking.Ģż Theyāre all, perhaps, do it in a different way but theyāre all on that journey to make sure that that can happen.Ģż Some are ahead of others.Ģż But itās not my job, as a government minister, to make councils and enforce them to use powers which they have the responsibility to carry out.Ģż But I think itās really important that we try and raise awareness more generally about the issue of pavement parking and that is why weāre also embarking on a nationwide communications campaign, using social media, using radio advertising to try and alert people to this issue.
Ģż
Communications campaign clip
Pavement parking is unsafe, unfair and illegal and you could be fined up to Ā£100 for it.Ģż Find out more and about exemptions at roadsafety.scot.
Ģż
White
Isnāt this, though, a bit aboutā¦ you mentioned the fines but this is about money as far as actually doing the work isnāt it?Ģż If I can just quote you a couple of the other councils which have made this kind of point.Ģż Inverclyde Council pointed us to a report from a meeting of their environmental and regeneration committee which says: āEnforcement will not be possible in Inverclyde without the necessary funding and resources for implementation and management, including the promotion of exemption orders.āĢż And they need to go through detailed assessments first to see whatās required.Ģż And Scottish Borders Council said: āLike most other Scottish local authorities weāre awaiting word from Transport Scotland on further funding opportunities to be made available to fund the enforcement of the new bill.Ģż The council will not be in a position to carry out enforcement of the new Transport Bill for the time being.āĢż
Ģż
Minister, is there going to be money for them?
Ģż
Hyslop
So, the councils have been given Ā£2.4 million to do the work that youāve been talking about, which has been about the exemption side of things and theyāve had the funding to enable them to do that.Ģż I canāt speak for Borders Council, so I canāt speak for Inverclyde Council but I can speak for the people of Scotland.Ģż The reason that this pavement parking ban was brought in was increasingly members of the Scottish Parliament were receiving complaints and concerns by, yes, people who have got visual impairments but also those people that have got double buggies or single buggies or older people walking with dogs ā a whole variety of people ā wheelchair users, who want to be able to use their pavements and to do so in a safe way and that is why we brought this forward.Ģż That is the correct responsibility of the Scottish government but we also respect councils and the powers and responsibilities they have.Ģż But I am absolutely convinced that they will be approached by their own constituents in their own areas demanding that they move faster and with more purpose, like Edinburgh Council, who will be bringing in their full powers by the end of January.
Ģż
White
But just to stay with that point.Ģż If itās a nationwide ban on pavement parking, which it is, shouldnāt it perhaps be funded by the nations, you know, because I mean we know hard pressed local authorities are?
Ģż
Hyslop
So, we have already provided funding for the initial work on the exemptions.Ģż We are in discussion with COSLA, who are the representative bodies of the councils, to identify what additional support they need to have to help support that rollout.Ģż But there has to be a political will here and if you believe that our pavements should be safe spaces for people, if you believe in fairness in our society and if you, as a council, want to serve all of your community, then you will do what Edinburgh Council have done and youāll take forward this and implement this.Ģż So, yes, we can provide enabling powers nationally, which is what weāve done but I would appeal to everybody to think about the type of country and the type of society we want and I want one where everybody can have access to their pavements and we can all benefit from that ban on pavement parking.
Ģż
White
Let me just finally, quickly, go back to Lyn ā Lyn Hetherington ā youāve got the ministerās ear, what would you like to see happen now?
Ģż
Hetherington
Well, by listening it sounds as if, yes, itās been passed, yes, you support it but it doesnāt sound as if the enforcement is something that is going to go any quicker than it has been since 2019 and itās the safety of lots of people that are using the pavements, as you say.
Ģż
White
Final response to that minister?
Ģż
Hyslop
Well, there was no movement before 2019 and not until weāve got the penalties brought in in December, so Iām perhaps more hopeful than Lyn.Ģż I do think that if she hasnāt already done so sheāll be contacting her local councillor to see what they can do to ensure that pavement parking in her part of Scotland can be implemented as quickly as it is in the city of Edinburgh.
Ģż
White
We may have to invite you both on again, to see how it is going.Ģż Lyn Hetherington and Scotlandās Transport Minister, Fiona Hyslop, thank you both very much.
Ģż
Both
Thank you.
Ģż
White
Meanwhile, in other parts of the UK I think I can hear some blind and partially sighted people saying ā well, at least Scotland is doing something.Ģż Although there are some parking bans notionally in place in England, in London, for example, there doesnāt seem to be much taking place in the way of enforcement.Ģż Iām joined now by Mike Bell, whoās the Thomas Pocklington Trustās Head of Public Affairs and Campaigns.
Ģż
Mike, just last week youāve reinforced a campaign, I think, thatās been running for some time.Ģż We know the issues, as weāve heard whatās happening, albeit more slowly than theyād like in Scotland, what are you calling for?
Ģż
Bell
What weāre calling for, Peter, is the government to get on and introduce legislation to ban pavement parking in England.Ģż Itās four years now since they first ran a consultation on taking action on pavement parking and we think itās just beyond time for a really clear and simple law that says pavement parking should be banned, the presumption should be that itās not allowed and then we would encourage the government to go down the line of giving councils the power to introduce pavement parking by exception but not by the norm.Ģż So, it would give the flexibility to local councils but the simple policy would be ā no pavement parking allowed in England.
Ģż
White
So, in other words, you accept that there are narrow roads, you accept that there are some circumstances where you need to be sure emergency vehicles can get through but you want the presumption to be that you donāt park on the pavement?
Ģż
Bell
Exactly right.Ģż We all recognise that there are some streets and some locations where pavement parking has got to be permitted but what we want is for that to be the exception and not the norm.
Ģż
White
You said four years but youāll know that campaigns, like yours, have been running now forā¦ well, well over 50 years.Ģż I mean I started working on this programme in the ā70s and it was one of the first things that I remember trying to cover, in particular, the campaign of the National Federation of the Blind.Ģż How do you think you can succeed where none of the others did?
Ģż
Bell
Well, in fairness, weāll give the government some credit that after, youāre exactly right, decades of campaigning on this issue by a huge range of organisations the government did finally consult, the Department for Transport ran their consultation back in 2020 and all weāre asking for now is for them to just move it on to the next stage.Ģż So, publish the results of the consultation and then introduce the legislation, as they said they were going to do.Ģż And nowās the time for the government to act.Ģż So, we are asking people to write to their MPs and to the Secretary of State for Transport, Mark Harper, and just ask them to get on with it.
Ģż
White
Well, we invited Mark Harper on, we were told he wasnāt available for interview, although we did get this statement from the department.Ģż They sayā¦ everyone should be able to navigate their streets without obstacles and while local authorities already have powers to prohibit through local regulation.Ģż āWe have consultedā¦ā ā as youāve said there ā āā¦on further helping them to take action. ĢżThe response to this will be published in due course.āĢż
Ģż
Itās always a slightly alarming phrase āin due courseā because you donāt know how due course is, do you?
Ģż
Bell
No, absolutely.Ģż I mean I think our message is really clear ā this is really a simple straightforward piece of legislation, this is not complicated, weāve got an existing model in Scotland, as you mentioned earlier there are other parts of England where there are private acts of parliament that have restricted pavement parking ā we just need a clear law to be introduced and they need to get on with it now.
Ģż
White
So, just to remind people what this is really about, weāre also joined by Dave Smith, heās an engagement manager for one of the trustās sight loss councils.Ģż Dave, I think youāve had not one but two close encounters with dangerously parked vehicles in the last few months?
Ģż
Smith
Yeah, I have.Ģż I come across parked vehicles every day I go out.Ģż One that kind of, I guess, it sticks in my mind quite a lot because it hurt, was I was walking out just around my local area, a very familiar area that I walk, Iām a long cane user and I walked straight into a scaffold pole that was sticking out the back of a scaffolding truck.Ģż Initially itās that ouch, a few expletives, I guess and then itās like ā where am I, why have I just walked into something so sharp and hard?Ģż And I realised that it was a truck that had parked completely on the pavement, blocking the pavement.
Ģż
White
How much damage did it do to you?
Ģż
Smith
Well, I wear glasses ā sunglasses ā just to try and block out some of the glare from the sun but it bent the glasses and it burst the top of my nose open and kind of bruised my ego.Ģż From my point of view as a blind person navigating, it just adds the additional kind of anxiety.Ģż I donāt walk as quickly because Iām now anticipating that somethingās going to be in my way and it shouldnāt be the case.
Ģż
White
So, youāve lost confidence, have you?Ģż It sounds as if you were probably quite a confident traveller.
Ģż
Smith
I think I still am a confident traveller and it takes quite a lot to knock me back but you know Iāve walked into the back of a truck before, Iāve walked into the back of an open boot before.Ģż Every time itās where your cane is on the ground and itās detecting stuff on the floor and your face detects the stuff higher up.Ģż But it does knock your confidence, it certainly does and it would quite easily put people off going out on their own.
Ģż
White
Dave Smith, Mike Bell ā thank you both very much for coming on.
Ģż
Just to say, as for Wales and Northern Ireland, well Wales a consultation was proposed for 2023, itās now been postponed until this year.Ģż Northern Ireland has conducted a consultation, theyāre waiting for a minister to be in place to make a decision based on its findings.
Ģż
And thatās it for today.Ģż As for next week though, weād like to hear in this election year from any visually impaired people thinking of standing, for whatever party, in the inevitable General Election.Ģż Do let us know if youāre running or you know of someone else whoās considering it.Ģż You can email intouch@bbc.co.uk or leave a voice message on 0161 8361338 or visit our website bbc.co.uk/intouch.
Ģż
From me, Peter White, producer Beth Hemmings and studio managers Carwyn Griffith and Simon Highfield, goodbye.
Ģż
Broadcast
- Tue 9 Jan 2024 20:40±«Óćtv Radio 4
Download this programme
Listen anytime or anywhere. Subscribe to this programme or download individual episodes.
Podcast
-
In Touch
News, views and information for people who are blind or partially sighted